The recent success of the U.S. men's national soccer team at the World Cup has sparked a debate about the nature of American soccer and its relationship with mainstream popularity. The author argues that the U.S. team's performance has brought in new, casual fans who are passionate about the sport, but some gatekeepers in the soccer media and industry are reacting negatively to this shift. This reaction is reminiscent of the WNBA's experience with Caitlin Clark, where the league initially sought growth but became defensive when new, mainstream attention emerged. The author believes that American soccer should embrace the influx of casual fans, as it represents a broader audience and a potential roadmap to success. By welcoming these new fans, the sport can expand its reach and become more inclusive, mirroring the values of the left that the author supports. The key takeaway is that American soccer should view the current moment as an opportunity for growth and inclusivity, rather than a threat to the established order.
